Mother's Day is Sunday! Shop in stores for last-minute gifts.
Save on Personalized Stationery! The more you buy, the more you save!
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
Login My Favorites

Cart View cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Sort by

2891 Results

Filters
Les Toupitis Zebra Plush Toy RattleLes Toupitis Zebra Plush Toy Rattle
Les Toupitis Zebra Plush Toy Rattle Sale price$19.99
Sold outLes Toupitis Elephant Plush Toy RattleLes Toupitis Elephant Plush Toy Rattle
Les Toupitis Elephant Plush Toy Rattle Sale price$24.99
Cowboy Tayto 4" Plush KeychainCowboy Tayto 4" Plush Keychain
Cowboy Tayto 4" Plush Keychain Sale price$15.00
Lucky Cat Tayto Potato PlushLucky Cat Tayto Potato Plush
Lucky Cat Tayto Potato Plush Sale price$32.00
Sold outMini Cityscape Snow GlobeMini Cityscape Snow Globe
Mini Cityscape Snow Globe Sale price$18.50
The Creatibles D.I.Y. Air-Dry Clay KitThe Creatibles D.I.Y. Air-Dry Clay Kit
The Creatibles D.I.Y. Air-Dry Clay Kit Sale price$21.99
Creature Crafts: My Pom-Pom Friends
Creature Crafts: My Pom-Pom Friends Sale price$18.00
Sold outGet Happy 3-Pack Mini Tins
Get Happy 3-Pack Mini Tins Sale price$14.99
Sold outScentsory Duos Popcorn/Pickle
Scentsory Duos Popcorn/Pickle Sale price$7.99
Save 30%Treaure Trove Thinking Putty Mega Tin
Treaure Trove Thinking Putty Mega Tin Sale price$27.99 Regular price$39.99
Sold outSeven Seas Thinking Putty Mega Tin
Seven Seas Thinking Putty Mega Tin Sale price$39.99
Hanging Planter OrnamentHanging Planter Ornament
Hanging Planter Ornament Sale price$11.99
Sold outBottle Brush Trees With LightsBottle Brush Trees With Lights
Bottle Brush Trees With Lights Sale price$29.95
Sold outMini Pom StockingsMini Pom Stockings
Mini Pom Stockings Sale price$12.95
Yeti's Mindfulness Plush & Book SetYeti's Mindfulness Plush & Book Set
Yeti's Mindfulness Plush & Book Set Sale price$49.99
Spiderman 12 OZ Kids CupSpiderman 12 OZ Kids Cup
Spiderman 12 OZ Kids Cup Sale price$39.95
It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Cocktails Socks
It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Cocktails Socks Sale price$6.99
Sold outClassic Kids Shark SunglessesClassic Kids Shark Sunglesses
Classic Kids Shark Sunglesses Sale price$12.00
Sold outSave 30%Vincent Van Gogh Wheat Fields with Cypress OrnamentVincent Van Gogh Wheat Fields with Cypress Ornament
Vincent Van Gogh Wheat Fields with Cypress Ornament Sale price$13.99 Regular price$19.99
Sold outVincent Van Gogh Irises OrnamentVincent Van Gogh Irises Ornament
Vincent Van Gogh Irises Ornament Sale price$19.99
Sold outSave 30%Pullback Santa in SleighPullback Santa in Sleigh
Pullback Santa in Sleigh Sale price$6.29 Regular price$8.99
11" Pusheen Toe Beans11" Pusheen Toe Beans
11" Pusheen Toe Beans Sale price$30.00
Sold outSwiss Miss Candle
Swiss Miss Candle Sale price$36.00
Sushi and Chopsticks BookmarksSushi and Chopsticks Bookmarks
Sushi and Chopsticks Bookmarks Sale price$6.50
Raccoon BookmarkRaccoon Bookmark
Raccoon Bookmark Sale price$6.50
Seaside Getaway 750 Piece PuzzleSeaside Getaway 750 Piece Puzzle
Seaside Getaway 750 Piece Puzzle Sale price$29.99
Washington DC Geometric Activities 1000 Piece PuzzleWashington DC Geometric Activities 1000 Piece Puzzle
Washington DC Geometric Activities 1000 Piece Puzzle Sale price$25.00
Sold outMarket Produce Bags Set of 3Market Produce Bags Set of 3
Market Produce Bags Set of 3 Sale price$17.99
Shine Bright Space Bound Magnetic Dress Up
Shine Bright Space Bound Magnetic Dress Up Sale price$13.99
Insect Lore Butterfly Farm Growing Kit with Prepaid VoucherInsect Lore Butterfly Farm Growing Kit with Prepaid Voucher
Insect Lore Butterfly Farm Growing Kit with Prepaid Voucher Sale price$34.99
Sold outBunny 100 pc fuzzy puzzleBunny 100 pc fuzzy puzzle
Bunny 100 pc fuzzy puzzle Sale price$11.99
Spelling PuzzlesSpelling Puzzles
Spelling Puzzles Sale price$19.99
Sold outThe Play Maysie Home Case Portable Travel DollhouseThe Play Maysie Home Case Portable Travel Dollhouse
The Play Maysie Home Case Portable Travel Dollhouse Sale price$49.99
Sold outPearl Picture FramePearl Picture Frame
Pearl Picture Frame Sale price$26.50
Sold outTaupe Candy Cottontails PlushTaupe Candy Cottontails Plush
Taupe Candy Cottontails Plush Sale price$15.99
Sold outCrossword Puzzle ornament
Crossword Puzzle ornament Sale price$24.99
Sold outAmerican Pekin Duck PlushAmerican Pekin Duck Plush
American Pekin Duck Plush Sale price$18.99
Sold outLively Bunny PlushLively Bunny Plush
Lively Bunny Plush Sale price$8.99
Sold outVintage Style FlaskVintage Style Flask
Vintage Style Flask Sale price$24.99
Sold outMini Menorah and 48 Cabdke SetMini Menorah and 48 Cabdke Set
Mini Menorah and 48 Cabdke Set Sale price$13.99
Clear Green Engraved Monogram SkewersClear Green Engraved Monogram Skewers
Clear Green Engraved Monogram SkewersPaper Source Sale price$34.95
Clear Engraved Monogram SkewersClear Engraved Monogram Skewers
Clear Engraved Monogram SkewersPaper Source Sale price$34.95
Clear Green Engraved Monogram StirrersClear Green Engraved Monogram Stirrers
Clear Green Engraved Monogram StirrersPaper Source Sale price$39.95
Clear Green Engraved Monogram CoastersClear Green Engraved Monogram Coasters
Clear Green Engraved Monogram CoastersPaper Source Sale price$49.95
Clear Engraved Monogram CoastersClear Engraved Monogram Coasters
Clear Engraved Monogram CoastersPaper Source Sale price$49.95
Pearl Rose Laser Cut Monogram SkewersPearl Rose Laser Cut Monogram Skewers
Pearl Rose Laser Cut Monogram SkewersPaper Source Sale price$34.95
Frosted Iris Laser Cut Monogram SkewersFrosted Iris Laser Cut Monogram Skewers
Frosted Iris Laser Cut Monogram SkewersPaper Source Sale price$34.95
Frosted Green Laser Cut Monogram SkewersFrosted Green Laser Cut Monogram Skewers
Frosted Green Laser Cut Monogram SkewersPaper Source Sale price$34.95

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!