Skip to content

Cart View cart

Your cart is empty

Stocking Stuffers

Sort by

99 Results

Filters

Legami Invisible Ink Pen - Magic Pen - UnicornLegami Invisible Ink Pen - Magic Pen - Unicorn
Needoh Funky PupNeedoh Funky Pup
Needoh Funky Pup Sale price$7.50
Gummy Bear Ornaments, Assorted
Rose Gold Compact Lighted MirrorRose Gold Compact Lighted Mirror
Chonk Cats Nesting Dolls
Chonk Cats Nesting Dolls Sale price$10.95
Macaron Ceramic Trinket Box
Macaron Ceramic Trinket Box Sale price$11.99
Legami Squishy Gel Pen - Squeezies - Kitty
Tortoise Bow Hair Clip
Tortoise Bow Hair Clip Sale price$14.99
Save 30%Ornament Lip BalmOrnament Lip Balm
Ornament Lip Balm Sale price$10.49 Regular price$14.99
Avocado Palm Pal
Avocado Palm Pal Sale price$15.50
Save 30%Bring Magic Mushroom Earrings
Bring Magic Mushroom Earrings Sale price$13.99 Regular price$19.99
Stylish Magnet
Stylish Magnet Sale price$6.00
Curled Up Cat Hair Clip
Curled Up Cat Hair Clip Sale price$14.99
Yoga DeckYoga Deck
Yoga Deck Sale price$22.95
Save 30%Copper Twinkle LightsCopper Twinkle Lights
Copper Twinkle Lights Sale price$9.06 Regular price$12.95
Tiny Book Light
Tiny Book Light Sale price$12.50
Save 30%Smoko Winter Wonderland Plush Keychain Blind BoxSmoko Winter Wonderland Plush Keychain Blind Box
Smoko Winter Wonderland Plush Keychain Blind Box Sale price$11.20 Regular price$16.00
Mindwave Page Markers - Corgi StandMindwave Page Markers - Corgi Stand
Midori Stickers - Feeling FacesMidori Stickers - Feeling Faces
Bob Ross Bobblehead: With Sound!
Matcha Vanilla Choco ScrubMatcha Vanilla Choco Scrub
Matcha Vanilla Choco Scrub Sale price$17.50
Hand Care Gift Set
Hand Care Gift Set Sale price$27.00
Gold Electronic Lighter
Gold Electronic Lighter Sale price$28.00
Corgi Power Bank
Corgi Power Bank Sale price$29.50
Champagne Satin PillowcaseChampagne Satin Pillowcase
Champagne Satin Pillowcase Sale price$21.50
Legami Squishy Gel Pen - Squeezies - Unicorn
Astro Cats Blind BoxAstro Cats Blind Box
Astro Cats Blind Box Sale price$15.00
Cherries Enamel Keychain
Cherries Enamel Keychain Sale price$18.00
Travel Sewing Kit Liberty StripeTravel Sewing Kit Liberty Stripe
Hohoho nail stickersHohoho nail stickers
Hohoho nail stickers Sale price$14.99
Save 30%Dotted Satin Wrapped Hair ClipDotted Satin Wrapped Hair Clip
Dotted Satin Wrapped Hair Clip Sale price$9.80 Regular price$14.00
Sold outSucculents Mini JournalsSucculents Mini Journals
Succulents Mini Journals Sale price$12.50
Dreamy Afternoon Manicure SetDreamy Afternoon Manicure Set
COOL CATS NEE DOHCOOL CATS NEE DOH
COOL CATS NEE DOH Sale price$4.99
Save 30%You're the Moon to My Star Friendship Bracelets
You're the Moon to My Star Friendship Bracelets Sale price$13.99 Regular price$19.99
Mindwave Sticky Notes - FrogMindwave Sticky Notes - Frog
Legami 3-In-1 Highlighter - 3 Is Better Than 1 - UnicornLegami 3-In-1 Highlighter - 3 Is Better Than 1 - Unicorn
Fish Hip Flask
Fish Hip Flask Sale price$29.99
Velvet Olive Minimergency Kit
Leopard Satin Claw ClipLeopard Satin Claw Clip
Leopard Satin Claw Clip Sale price$14.50
Star Fuzzy Slipper Socks
Star Fuzzy Slipper Socks Sale price$14.99
Save 30%Pearlescent Beaded Bracelet
Pearlescent Beaded Bracelet Sale price$10.15 Regular price$14.50
Save 30%BELIEVE Pen SetBELIEVE Pen Set
BELIEVE Pen Set Sale price$12.25 Regular price$17.50
Cheese Wine Charms
Cheese Wine Charms Sale price$12.95
Frog Tea InfuserFrog Tea Infuser
Frog Tea Infuser Sale price$11.99
Duck Duck Drink Tea InfuserDuck Duck Drink Tea Infuser
Duck Duck Drink Tea Infuser Sale price$15.99
Save 30%William Morris Soap In A TinWilliam Morris Soap In A Tin
William Morris Soap In A Tin Sale price$11.89 Regular price$16.99
Sold outGuitar MultitoolGuitar Multitool
Guitar Multitool Sale price$24.99

BEST STOCKING STUFFERS 2025

Hang your stockings by the chimney with care, but don’t forget to fill them first with the best stocking stuffers from Paper Source! We have an amazing selection of cute, fun and quirky stocking stuffers to wow your spouses, children and colleagues this holiday season. From candy to toys to socks, our collection has the perfect little gifts for everyone on your list!

Stocking Stuffer Ideas for Everyone on Your List

Shop stocking stuffer ideas from Paper Source and find the best stocking stuffers for men and women. Whether you are looking for stocking stuffers for wife, husband, kids, friends or coworkers, these gifts are the perfect little packages for slipping into stockings this holiday season.

Stocking Stuffers for Adults & Kids

Shop self-care essentials such as face masks, manicure sets, essential oils and candles. Find cute jewelry and hair accessories such as bracelets, hairclips and fingernail stickers. Browse desk essentials such as desk calendars, journals, pen sets and more. Look through travel basics such as keychains, luggage tags, tech accessories and tote bags. Find stocking stuffers for kids such as cards, games and toys. We even have a wide selection of quirky stocking stuffers, sure to make your friends and family laugh this holiday season. Still not sure what to get? Look through our Holiday Gift Guide or purchase a Paper Source Gift Card!

Perfect Stocking Stuffers for your Holiday Gift Exchange!

Find the perfect stocking stuffers for your Holiday Gift Exchange, White Elephant or Secret Santa at Paper Source! Stocking stuffers are the perfect small gift for your holiday exchange and are great gifted on their own! You’ll have everyone trying to steal your gift! Put your stocking stuffer in a Holiday Treat Bags for an extra festive touch!

FAQ About Stocking Stuffers 2025

What are good things to put in a stocking?

If you are searching for some good stocking fillers, here are a few great ideas:

Candy

Gift Cards

Small Games & Toys

Candles & Wellness Gifts

Socks, Scarves, & Gloves

2026 Calendars, Planners and Journals

Books

Novelty mugs, Magnets & Keychains

Art Supplies

What traditionally goes in a stocking?

Traditionally stockings are filled with fruit, candy and toys or other small gifts.

How many gifts should be in a stocking?

While there is no set number as to the number of gifts that should go in your stocking, most stockings are filled with 3-5 small stocking stuffers.

Our Top Picks for Stocking Stuffers 2025

Hand Drawn Scallop Pink Luggage tag

Inflatable Tube Guy

Pressssit! Fidget Toy

You Got This Essential Oil Roller Set

Paper Source Physical Gift Card

Grey Cat Fuzzy Crew Socks

Leopard Satin Claw Clip

Koosh Mondo Ball

The Perfect Phone Stand

You may also be interested in…

Personalized Gift Guide

Kids’ Toys and Games

Holiday & Christmas Themed Gifts