Christmas-Themed Gifts

Go to slide 1
Go to slide 2
Go to slide 3
Go to slide 4

Your cart is empty

Holiday & Christmas Themed Gifts

Make someone’s Christmas or Hanukkah extra special this year with holiday themed gifts from Paper Source! Shop holiday and Christmas themed gifts, perfect for stocking stuffers, white elephant or Secret Santa gift exchanges! Small Christmas and Holiday themed presents make great gifts for anyone who loves the holidays.

Small Christmas Gifts & More

Shop holiday socks that they can show off on Christmas morning, or holiday oven mittens and tea towels that will put the chef in the kitchen in the holiday spirit. From colorful Christmas mugs to unique pop culture ornaments that will make your family and friends laugh out loud to Hanukkah candles and sparkly New Year’s Eve glasses, explore our holiday and Christmas themed gift selection to find something fun! Holiday scented candles will make good stocking stuffers or perfect gifts for this year’s holiday get-togethers, and holiday games or jigsaw puzzles are a great idea for a work gift exchange. So, whether you’re buying presents for a winter holiday lover or searching for festive grab bag gifts, find them all at Paper Source stores and online.

Gift Exchange Ideas for Christmas

We have great small gifts for Christmas gift exchanges, white elephant and Secret Santa. Holiday themed gifts are always a big hit and can be used by the recipient for years to come. Can’t decide what to gift? Consider a Paper Source gift card for your favorite crafter or stationery aficionado! Our gifts are so good, you may want to keep them for yourself!

Looking for even more gift ideas? Check out our Holiday Gift Guide for more Christmas present ideas and inspiration!

FAQ About Holiday & Christmas Themed Gifts

How does a holiday gift exchange work?

Most holiday gift exchanges operate around a simple principle: give a gift, get a gift! After that, there may be different rules about what kind of gift to bring or the amount of money spent depending on what type of gift exchange you are participating in.

What is the Christmas gift exchange called?

There are many different types of Christmas gift exchanges. Some of the most popular gift exchanges are White Elephant, Secret Santa, Favorite Things and Grab Bag!

How much should I spend on Christmas gift exchange?

A general rule for a Christmas gift exchange is to spend between $5 and $20, but you may choose to spend more or less depending on your budget.

What is a grab bag Christmas?

The basic principle behind a grab bag Christmas is that each person puts a gift - practical or silly - inside a large bag. Then, each person goes around and pulls one gift out of the bag!

8 Fun Small but Festive Christmas Gift Ideas

Festive Christmas socks

Colorful holiday mugs

Winter scene jigsaw puzzles

Holiday oven mitts & kitchen towels

Funny adult games

Pop culture Christmas tree ornaments

Holiday beanies

Christmassy scented candles